Former PlayStation Boss Criticizes Nintendo Switch 2, Calls It "Better Switch" Instead of Innovation

Ex-Sony president Shuhei Yoshida has expressed disappointment with Nintendo's upcoming Switch 2 console, suggesting the gaming giant is "losing its identity" by choosing to upgrade its previous system rather than create something completely new.

In an interview with the Easy Allies Podcast last week, Yoshida shared his thoughts on Nintendo's latest hardware reveal. "For me, Nintendo is always about creating a new experience, like designing hardware and games together to create something amazing," he explained. "But Switch 2, as we all anticipated, is a better Switch, right?"

The Nintendo Switch 2, finally unveiled in January 2025 after years of rumors, features several technical improvements, including a larger screen, a more powerful processor, 4K resolution, and 120 frames-per-second capability. While these upgrades sound impressive, Yoshida believes they represent a departure from Nintendo's innovative past.

According to Yoshida, Nintendo has traditionally stood out by taking creative risks with unique console designs like the Wii or the original Switch. Now, he feels they're following the iterative approach that PlayStation and Xbox have used for years. "Because it's a better Switch, the core premise of the whole Switch 2 is 'we made things better.' And that's something other companies have been doing all the time," he noted during the podcast.

Yoshida also questioned Nintendo's decision to charge $9.99 for "Welcome Tour," a tutorial game designed to introduce players to the new console's features. According to him, this represents "an opportunity loss for Nintendo" rather than something that will create significant backlash.

He drew comparisons to Sony's approach with the PlayStation 5, which included "Astro's Playroom" as a free game with every console purchase. This title served as both an entertaining platformer and a showcase for the PS5's new controller features.

"I just don't understand. You would want everyone to experience that, right? You would have a better understanding of the Switch and become a fan of the system," Yoshida added.

While critical of these decisions, Yoshida did attempt to see Nintendo's perspective, suggesting the company is "preserving the value of software" and maintains a stance "against free-to-play" games.

The Nintendo Switch 2's April presentation revealed several features that excited fans, including the promise of more third-party games coming to the platform. Games like "Elden Ring" and "Mario Kart World" were highlighted during the presentation.

However, Yoshida noted that the addition of third-party titles would only be exciting "if your gaming was only on Nintendo hardware," pointing out that many gamers own multiple consoles and may have already played these games elsewhere.

As the June 3 launch date approaches, it remains to be seen whether the Nintendo Switch 2 will live up to expectations and whether Nintendo's strategy shift will pay off in the competitive gaming market.